Monday, October 17, 2016

A multitude of selves

Paul Bloom says in his article First Person Plural, "The idea is that instead, within each brain, different selves are continually popping in and out of existence. They have different desires, and they fight for control—bargaining with, deceiving, and plotting against one another." He argues that instead of one singular self thinking in your head, there are actual multiple selves fighting each other in your head, almost like a civil war within yourself. I agree with his statement, because when faced with decisions, an answer to my question or problem is not immediately made. When sitting down, I have to contemplate the good repercussions and the bad repercussions of an argument. Sometimes the side with the bad repercussions win due to my other selves arguing against the good such as fear and stubbornness. This can be related to the movie Inside Out. Although a children's animation, it holds a great likeness to what Bloom is saying in his article. Each personality that we have, whether it's kindness, selfishness, fear, generosity, all play against each other at every moment of the day. All those different selves make us into the person we think, or know, we are. For instance, in the mornings, my reasonable and knowledgeable side tells me that I know the best thing for me is to wake up early and make a healthy, hearty breakfast consisting of eggs, bacon, fruit, and an English muffin, but the lazy and tired side of me tells me, "Hey, it'll be so much easier to just make a bowl of Cocoa Puffs, plus they're more delicious." I reason with myself that I can work out and work it off, but in reality I know I won't. Yet, I still eat the Cocoa Puffs. These are all of my selves fighting against each other. They're all talking at once to make up one cognitive decision, but due to the difference of all of them, decisions differ. Therefore, that allows one to grow into their personality, or who they are. So, yes I believe in Paul Bloom's idea of a multitude of selves living in one individual's brain.

2 comments:

  1. I agree with your statements. I believe in Paul Bloom’s idea of a multitude of selves living in one individual’s brain. Paul Bloom states in his article, First Person Plural, “the alternative view keeps the angel and the devil, but casts aside the person in between.” From this I believe that we do have alternative selves. Self-thinking consists of various ideas going against each other and you choose the idea where you feel more confident in defending. Just like you stated, we think of our decisions before putting them into action. Some may decide to go the easy way or others may decide to go the hard way. For instance, deciding what to wear to class each day. I can pick an outfit or I can use running shorts and a shirt. If it is simpler, I always go to the second option because having 8am’s doesn’t give you much time to get all dressed up if you’re not a morning person. Also, breakfast wise, I eat cereal instead of the healthy breakfast because sometimes it is time consuming when the time is limited. We decide our mood on a daily basis and it all depends on how you feel. It is constant juxtaposition within your brain of what you decide to do, wear, eat, etc. This demonstrates how we are made of multitudes. The movie, Inside Out depicts the way our mind works. I agree that it shows our multitudes because of the different characters that we come across.

    ReplyDelete
  2. I do believe that we are made up of multiple personalities/selves. In the article, Bloom says," We benefit, intellectually and personally, from the interplay between different selves..." which to me means that our multiple selves allows us to grow and become better human beings. For example, when I am faced with the everyday task of whether or not to get up early in the morning for class, I am arguing with myself in my head all the pros and cons, and all the possibilities of going to class or not. The mature side of me says to go and my more immature laid back side says not to. I am at odds with myself and when I make a decision I am either further prompting and bettering myself or not based on what I choose to do. These kind of scenarios happen daily and are just part of our everyday life whether we realize it or not. For me, these everyday "fights" between my selves help shape who I am and the person I will become as I continue to grow. I also feel it is important to understand how we work and function within ourselves if we are truly to begin to understand the possibilities of the human mind.

    ReplyDelete